C.S. Lewis' 'masterpiece', Till We Have Faces is extraordinarily illusive. I swear to god there is literally no online help on it whatsoever. Therefore, seeing as it's one of my A-Level texts, that puts me in a wee bit of a pickle. So, in order to save others the 6 hours of work that it took me to write my two essays, feel free to take a look. Aren't I nice...
By the way, if anyone plagiarises my work, I will cry. You have been warned.
How Does Lewis Simultaneously Release All The Information We Need To Us Whilst Maintaining The Illusion That Orual Is Writing For Her Own Period?
Till
We Have Faces opens with our protagonist, Orual, who is seen
through two sets of eyes. At the beginning of the book, Orual,
in a way, has two faces: that of the naïve child of her
past and the bitter, twisted old woman she has become. This is
most prominent in the line: ‘that was the
first time I realised that I am ugly.’
The change of tense simultaneously represents Orual’s childhood
realisation-this was-;
and how this has haunted her throughout her life-I am-. Orual is
writing for a very specific purpose: she is retelling the story of
her life ‘to accuse the gods… as if I were making my complaint
before a judge’ with the hope that it may be read in
the Greeklands, where they can decide whether or not the gods
have been just towards her. In this way, Orual is writing
for her own period and time- she is registering her complaint
concerning the gods. However, this is also a tool used by Lewis in
order to slowly reveal to us the information that we need. This
manifests itself in three different ways throughout the text:
foreshadowing, the unreliable narrator, and the language of the text.
Firstly,
foreshadowing. The entire book is littered with foreshadowing. Future
events are constantly hinted at; for example, the book starts with
the lines: ‘I am old now and have not much to fear from the anger
of gods. I have no husband nor child, nor hardly a friend through
whom they can hurt me.’ Though merely the opening passage to Till
We Have Faces, we can ascertain from this so much: firstly, we are
told that she has 'not much to fear from the anger of gods'. This
implies that she may have done or be about to do something the gods
may not approve of. Secondly, we can assume that she is lonely. 'I
have no husband nor child, nor hardly a friend'. From this we can
ascertain conclusions about how her life has played out because,
thirdly, she says: ‘I am old now.' All this information we pick up
on, and we recognise. Foreshadowing is a technique here used
throughout the book to ready us for events to come. For example: ‘the
god of the Grey Mountain, who hates me, is the son of Ungit.’
This prepares us for events concerning the god of the Grey Mountain,
letting us know of future interaction and bad feeling between them.
Another example would be when Orual says ‘I do not know
that I have ever (to speak of things merely mortal) been in such
dread’. This readies us for things not strictly mortal, readies us
to step outside the boundaries of the natural world and into a world
where things may not be as they seem. Throughout the book, Lewis
uses Orual to forewarn and prepare us for what is to come.
Maintaining the pretext that Orual is writing to complain,
to report, Lewis uses her to work to hint of things to come; so that
when these events do occur, we are more than ready.
Secondly,
the unreliable narrator. Orual is an unreliable narrator
for a number of different reasons. Firstly, in the beginning of the
book, she is a child. She has a child’s mind and understanding, and
thus our understanding, through her, may be limited. Secondly, she is
‘old now’ and her memories and recollections may have become
faded through time; finally, and perhaps most importantly, Orual is
angry, and resentful: ‘I will accuse the gods, especially the god
who lives on the Grey Mountain’. These emotions do not facilitate
impartiality. The book is related to us from Orual’s point of view,
which considering her aims, may be biased. However what does this
allow Lewis to do? The technique of the unreliable narrator allows
Lewis to release the information we need, but in a form that cannot
be trusted. Orual fails to understand many things about
herself and those around her. In her reportage, she may aim to
present an unbiased, evaluation of the events that have passed, but
her interpretation and understanding of what is happening to other
characters cannot be fully relied upon. Lewis guides us through the
book in this manner, so that to the alert reader, the revelations at
the end are no surprise: they have already seen through the mistakes
and self-deceptions Orual has made along the way. In this
manner, Lewis releases the information that we need to us, allowing
us to foresee the path that the book will take; however throughout
the book, we retain the illusion that Orual is writing for
her own period: at first to register her complaint with the people of
her time, and then to retract it.
Finally,
the language of the book. Language is what reveals the events of the
story to us- through it the story is told. The language used to tell
this story is chosen very carefully and specifically. We see this in
several different ways, the most important of which is its alienness.
Phrases occur throughout the book which we are perfectly capable of
understanding, but jar in our consciousness: ‘shore me’; ‘we
were booted’; ‘greyed the last red hair’; ‘the Ungit-smell’;
‘a small rain beginning’; for all of these phrases, our
understanding of the concepts expressed is the same, but they give us
a foreign feeling, an alien feeling. It separates us from the body of
the text, making it feel like Orual is writing for a
different time, almost a different world. This allows us to stand at
a distance from the book and observe. By preventing us from becoming
lost in the plot, Lewis allows us to become observers, not readers.
Till We Have Faces, Lewis’ masterpiece, is not just a story, it has
a moral. It does not merely tell of events that have occurred
to Orual, but is a record of Orual’s self-realisation and
awareness. By using the phrases referenced above ('shore me', 'a
small rain beginning'), Lewis makes us stop, think and consider;
which in turn helps us to understand what he is trying to convey.
Lewis uses language to hold us at a distance from the story, hiding
this behind the pretext of a culture which is alien and different to
ours in so many ways.
In
conclusion, Lewis uses a variety of techniques to maintain the
illusion that Orual’s intent when writing Till We Have Faces is at
first to register her complaint, and then to retract it. He also
employs these techniques to release information to us in a variety of
methods throughout the book: His use of foreshadowing prepares us for
what is to come through Orual’s simple, first-person narration. His
second technique of the unreliable narrator allows us to experience
not only the plot development of Till We Have Faces, but also the
character development of Orual as she awakens to this
self-realisation throughout the book. Finally, Lewis uses language
masterfully to deceive our minds into believing not only
that Orual is writing for her own time period, through the
construction of grammar in ways less familiar to us, therefore
creating an alien feel to the text; but he also uses this feeling of
alienation to separate us from the text, allowing us to stand at a
distance, and in some ways, be the audience she wanted so desperately
at the beginning of the book- to reassure herself that it was not she
who was wrong, but she who had been wronged: ‘Perhaps
their wise men will know whether my complaint is right or whether the
god could have defended himself if he had made an answer.’
What Are The Key Things That We Need To Know/Carry Forward For The Rest of the Story? What Has, In Some Way, Been Highlighted?
Throughout
the first few chapters of C.S. Lewis' Till We Have Faces, certain
elements are highlighted which then go on to appear again and again
throughout the story. These recurring themes or ideas form the
ideology of the novel, each coming to its own separate conclusion.
The main themes of Till We Have Faces include: Barbarianism, Death,
Misogyny, and Love.
Firstly,
barbarianism. Highlighted especially strongly throughout Orual's
childhood, we are constantly shown how in Glome, life can be both
barbaric and cruel. Our first example of this is seen in interaction
between the Fox and Orual: 'we sometimes, in a bad year, have to cut
someone's throat and pour the blood over [Ungit]'. Animal and human
sacrifice are integral to the cult of the Goddess Ungit; however the
barbarianism of this practice, even for the age in which the book is
set, is highlighted by Fox's reaction to Orual's words: 'He shuddered
when I said that and muttered something under his breath.' The stark
differences between the Greek culture and Glome's culture is thus
shown- highlighting for us the barbarianism of Glome as a whole. The
theme of barbarianism continues throughout the first chapters of the
book: King Trom, in grief and anger, stabs a wine steward to death
and threatens to send the Fox to the mines- a certain death sentence.
Orual encourages her tutor to flee, but he prefers honourable
suicide. He will be 'resolved into our elements'; however despite
this belief, he still trembles. Again, barbarianism is highlighted
within this passage- the Fox asks Orual 'are you still a barbarian?'
when she reminds him of the doctrines of the worship of Ungit- that
those who commit suicide 'lie wallowing in filth- down there in the
land of the dead.' The contrast between the faiths of the Greek
Culture and Glome's culture is again strong here, with Orual's faith
presented as barbaric, and the Fox's as noble and 'according to
nature'. This theme continues and develops throughout the novel, and
in a way, Orual's development of self-awareness at the end of the
book can be seen as her passage from the barbaric way of thinking
that she upholds before, to the civilised understanding she develops.
The
theme of barbarianism within the novel links in strongly with the
theme of death. Life is cheap in Till We Have Faces, with instances
of premature, natural death; sacrifice; murder; certain death
sentences; and discussion of suicide occurring within the first two
chapters alone. This theme, highlighted in such concentration at the
beginning of the book, continues throughout. The people of Glome
worship Psyche for her 'healing touch', however upon the Priest of
Ungit's announcement that Psyche must be offered as expiation, they
soon turn on her. Drought and plague disappear following Psyche's
death, which the Fox interprets as a coincidence, but denies that
Psyche's death was in vain for she died 'full of … courage and
patience' and 'to love, and to lose what we love are equally things
appointed for our nature'. This quote displays the Fox's belief that
Psyche's death has not been for nothing, as both love and loss are
given to us by the gods to help us grow and become stronger. This
theme of death continues throughout the novel, but is initially
highlighted to us in the very beginning: we are first presented with
with abstract concepts of death through sacrifice, then natural
death, then the murder of the wine steward, the famine and plagues of
the masses, building up to the apparent death of a character we have
come to love- Psyche, a character who makes 'beauty all around her'.
Thus, as we navigate the beginning of the book, the theme of death is
slowly introduced to us, with each occurrence of the theme growing in
gravity and seriousness, until it reaches a crescendo with the
supposed death of Psyche. In this way, the theme of death is
highlighted to us gradually, but powerfully.
The
third theme we see within the book is that of misogyny. King Trom,
Orual's father is openly contemptuous of his three daughters,
assigning them to the care of slaves. His eldest two daughters
receive an education only because Trom wants his educated Greek
slave, the Fox, to hone his skills for his future sons: 'if a man can
teach a girl, he can teach anything.' This theme is even present in
the normally educated and wise Fox, who is offended by women who do
not cover their faces with a veil; however as a slave, he must remain
silent. The matter of succession is also an issue within the text, as
with no male heirs, Orual inherits Trom's throne. Despite the
suggestion of a hasty match with some royal from a neighbouring
kingdom, Orual decides that as she has grown up with the derision of
her father for being a girl (and an ugly girl at that), she will rule
alone. Orual laments that the only crime the gods consider
unforgivable is one that cannot be remedied- that of being born
female. Misogyny is a theme present throughout the book, and is the
driving force behind many pivotal moments of the book, for example,
where Orual comes to a realisation that 'this is where men, even the
trustiest, fail us' and that she is the only one who truly cares for
Psyche: 'She lives at the very outskirts of their thoughts... You are
alone Orual... No help will come.' From this she makes the decision
to embark upon the disastrous second trip up the Grey Mountain.
Misogyny is present throughout the book, but is highlighted to aid
our awareness and understanding of the novel from the very beginning.
The
final and most important theme is that of love. The characters in
Till We Have Faces display complex examples of love- both platonic
and sexual. As a child, Orual loves her half-sister Psyche above all.
The love that Orual has for her sister is unhealthy- it takes rather
than gives. Orual's love for Psyche is such that she desires her for
her own happiness, not for Psyche's happiness. Evidence for this can
be seen where Orual claims her half-sister as her possession: 'she
was mine. Mine. Do
you not know what the words mean? Mine!' This idea of possessive,
destructive love is displayed from the very beginning of the novel.
Orual's attachment to Psyche, the pleasure she receives from her
presence and her protective, possessive dominance over her all
foreshadow the love that is to develop and fester between them.
However, Lewis also contrasts Orual's inability to love truly and
freely with examples of real, giving, sacrificing love. The Fox
realises he shouldn't use his love to beg Orual to refrain from
fighting Argon, and says: 'I was wrong to weep and beg and try to
force you by your love', here showing his understanding of how the
power that love gives you over a person should not be exploited.
Orual displays her unawareness of this concept where she says to
Unsit that she could have forced Bardia to stay home. Unsit replies
with indignation, saying: 'keep him to myself at all cost? Make him
so mine that he was no longer his?… Queen Orual, I begin to think
you know nothing of love.' Through this theme, Lewis not only
deconstructs false love, but also shows by contrast, the beauty of
true, pure, giving, sacrificial love. Orual's misconceptions about
love are highlighted at the start of the novel, and we follow them
through to the very end, where Orual realises, understands and
repents of the errors of her ways.
In
conclusion, the themes that we see at the beginning of the novel,
including Barbarianism, Death, Misogyny, and Love, play crucial roles
within the novel as a whole. Lewis highlights ideas to us for very
specific reasons, namely so that we can follow them throughout the
course of the novel, watching them develop, change, and at the end,
conclude.
© Izzy Garratt 2012
No comments:
Post a Comment